Lev Ladaas

Writings · Avodah

Is the Simcha About You, or About the Simcha?

The host is watching who came. The guest is checking if he was seen. Both are at the same simcha, and both are playing the same game.

· 6 min read

Contents8 sections
  1. Two people, one game
  2. The guest came to give
  3. The host can fall into it too
  4. A clean simcha
  5. Why the todah came with so much bread
  6. The guest brings a todah too
  7. And then comes the applause
  8. One question before every simcha

The hall is full. The music is playing. And the host is standing near the door, watching the room.

Who came? Who didn’t? Did they like the food? Did they notice the flowers? What are they going to say about it tomorrow?

For weeks before, it was invitations, reminders, guest lists, seating charts, menus, pictures. Making sure everyone knew. Making sure the right people came. Making sure it all looked right.

Now the night is here, and he can’t quite enjoy it. He’s too busy keeping score.

Two people, one game

Across the room, a guest is keeping score too.

Before he came, he asked himself: Should I go? Is it worth it? Who else will be there? Will it be awkward if I don’t show up?

Now that he’s here: Did I give mazel tov yet? Did I dance with the chosson? Did they see me?

The host wants something from the guests. The guests want something from the simcha. Two people, standing in the same room, playing the same game. And the name of the game is me.

But a simcha was never meant to be that.

The guest came to give

When you walk into a wedding, you aren’t there to collect anything. You aren’t there to get your mazel tov in, or to make sure you danced with the chosson.

Someone else has a simcha, and you’ve been given a chance to be part of it. You came to give: to honor, to be mesameach, to add your joy to theirs.

The Gemara puts it sharply:

כׇּל הַנֶּהֱנֶה מִסְּעוּדַת חָתָן וְאֵינוֹ מְשַׂמְּחוֹ עוֹבֵר בַּחֲמִשָּׁה קוֹלוֹת, שֶׁנֶּאֱמַר: ״קוֹל שָׂשׂוֹן וְקוֹל שִׂמְחָה קוֹל חָתָן וְקוֹל כַּלָּה קוֹל אוֹמְרִים הוֹדוּ אֶת ה׳ צְבָאוֹת״

Berachos 6b

Notice what it doesn’t say. It doesn’t say that whoever shows up has done his part. It says that if you benefit from the meal, you owe the chosson his joy. You ate his food; now give him something.

The direction runs from me to him, not from him to me.

Even mazel tov can turn inward. Did I already give mazel tov? As if it were a box to check. The point was never that I said it. The point is that they should feel the warmth of people who came just to share their happiness.

The host can fall into it too

The host thinks he is the giver. Look how many people I’m feeding. Look at this beautiful simcha I’m making for everyone.

But underneath, a different question can be running: What will they think of me? Will they say it was a beautiful wedding? Did I make the right impression?

Now he needs them. Their attendance, their compliments, their approval.

And once a simcha becomes a trade between two egos, I give you a meal so you give me admiration; I give you my presence so you give me credit, it starts to turn sour. Everyone is taking. Nobody is really celebrating.

A clean simcha

There is a much cleaner way to see it.

A person makes a simcha because Hashem gave him something to be happy about, and he wants to thank Him. But he doesn’t want to thank Him alone. He wants other people inside that thanks.

I have something to thank Hashem for. Come celebrate His kindness with me.

That is exactly what Dovid HaMelech says:

אוֹדֶה ה׳ מְאֹד בְּפִי וּבְתוֹךְ רַבִּים אֲהַלְלֶנּוּ

Tehillim 109:30

I will thank Hashem greatly with my mouth, and among many I will praise Him.

The thanks goes public. Not because I need an audience, but because Hashem’s goodness deserves to be shared. Now the guests aren’t there to serve themselves, and the host isn’t making the simcha to serve himself. Everyone has gathered around something bigger than all of them.

Why the todah came with so much bread

The Torah built this idea right into a korban.

A person who was saved from danger brought a korban todah. Along with the animal came forty loaves of bread, far more than one family could eat. And all of it had to be eaten in a single day and night, much less time than an ordinary shelamim gets.

Why so much bread, and why so little time? The Sforno explains:

וּבְרִבּוּת הַלֶּחֶם יִתְפַּרְסֵם הַנֵּס לְאוֹכְלִים רַבִּים, וְכֻלָּם נֶאֱכָלִים בִּזְמַן קָדְשֵׁי קָדָשִׁים שֶׁהֵם לְיוֹם וָלַיְלָה

Sforno on Vayikra 7:11

He can’t sit in a corner and eat his korban quietly. There is too much, and too little time. He has to bring people in. And as they eat, they hear the story: what happened to him, and how Hashem saved him.

The person who received the kindness becomes the person who gives others a chance to thank Hashem with him.

That’s a simcha. Not look what happened to me, but look what Hashem did. Come thank Him with me.

The guest brings a todah too

Go back to that Gemara about the wedding guest. It doesn’t end with the warning. It goes on to say what happens to the guest who does make the chosson happy:

רַבִּי אֲבָהוּ אָמַר: כְּאִילּוּ הִקְרִיב תּוֹדָה

Berachos 6b

As if he brought a korban todah.

The guest who dances, blesses, encourages and lifts the chosson isn’t just a spectator at someone else’s thanksgiving. He has joined it. His joy is part of the fifth voice the Gemara listed: קוֹל אוֹמְרִים הוֹדוּ אֶת ה׳.

That is why Chazal care so much about the guests. A wedding isn’t an event they happen to attend. Their presence, their dancing, their brachos are part of the avodah of the day.

And that is also why the ego is so out of place there. The moment the guest asks what am I getting out of this?, something has shifted. The moment the host asks what am I getting from everyone who came?, it has shifted there too.

And then comes the applause

Sometimes the shift is easiest to see at the end of the night, when everyone gathers around the host.

What a beautiful simcha! Everything was perfect! What a host!

There is a place for that. Hakaras hatov to the people who worked hard is real, and it matters.

But if we aren’t careful, the focus moves without anyone noticing. The simcha began with Hashem. Now everyone is praising the food, the hall, the family, the host, the way it was all done. And Hashem, the reason there was anything to celebrate in the first place, has slipped into the background.

That’s the irony. We gathered to celebrate something holy, and we ended up celebrating ourselves.

One question before every simcha

There is a simple question a person can ask before any simcha: Is this about me, or about the simcha?

When I’m the host: am I inviting people because I want them with me in thanking Hashem, or because I need their attention?

When I’m the guest: am I going because I want to give joy, or because I need something from the evening?

And when we’re all together: are we celebrating ourselves, or the One who gave us something to celebrate?

A real simcha takes the ego out of the center. Not the host, not the guest, not the food, not the compliments. Hashem is in the center.

And then something beautiful happens. The host gets to give. The guest gets to give.

The host can stand by the door again and watch the room. But now he isn’t counting who came. He is looking at a hall full of people who came to thank Hashem with him, and that is the best thing in it.

Everyone goes home having been part of something that was never about them in the first place.

That’s a simcha.

Inspired byChovos HaLevavos, Shaar HaBitachon #351: Whom are we trying to please? And about complimentsby Harav Shimon Spitzer

Share this article

Print as a gilyon

In the print window, choose “Save as PDF” to keep a copy.

Press Esc to close